Top 10 whisky from Islay

Are you searching for the best whisky from Islay? Here is our list of the best whiskies from the Islay region rated by Whiskybase members. Hard to pick the correct bottle? We have selected 10 bottles of whisky from Islay often reviewed and enjoyed by our members. You can't go wrong with a selection from this list.

Reviewed by the valued members of Whiskybase.

Ardbeg Lord of the Isles

91.31 / 100 Gemiddelde score

800 Stemmen & 47 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 2505.91
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 5 online shops

“Quick hit review.

I'm not an Ardbeg fanboy, far from it - but who would pass on a chance to taste the legendary Lord of Isles? On the nose, mineral, briny and sooty notes are complemented by orange zest, peaches and tobacco. Magnificent…” Lees verder

Lagavulin 1995

90.19 / 100 Gemiddelde score

609 Stemmen & 131 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 448.40
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 11 online shops

“Fantastic, no comparison to the current Distillers Editions. He also does not need more Vol.%, But he is just as he is, just good.” Lees verder

Lagavulin 1985

93.06 / 100 Gemiddelde score

557 Stemmen & 102 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 4283.38
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 21 online shops

“Bottles # 1145, # 3376 and # 3428 sold empty at ebay.” Lees verder

Laphroaig 21-year-old

90.06 / 100 Gemiddelde score

536 Stemmen & 111 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 300.92
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 10 online shops

“Of course, such an expensive malt for a special event raises certain expectations, no question. Since I could not gain access to the flavors at first, despite hours of hiding, disappointment was already spreading. I had not expected anything…” Lees verder

Ardbeg 1977

90.43 / 100 Gemiddelde score

504 Stemmen & 67 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 1472.14
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 14 online shops

“Give it a little time in the glass and it will be heavenly. I've had a few 70s Speysiders before, but this is my first 70s Islay. This clearly stands out from the others.
New bottle opened. Same thing, give time in the glass. It is worth…” Lees verder

Laphroaig 1991

90.02 / 100 Gemiddelde score

472 Stemmen & 87 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 791.88
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 16 online shops

“An empty bottle was sold for 70,99€ at ebay.
The capsule was not harmed for opening the bottle.
So be careful if somebody offers you a bottle with bottle number 0986.
eBay-Artikelnummer:  151892120215

It is a shame that Laphroaig…” Lees verder

Laphroaig 30-year-old

92.08 / 100 Gemiddelde score

451 Stemmen & 57 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 3130.24
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 5 online shops

“There are many different versions of this bottle and only a couple of them are listed on WhiskyBase. These notes are for a 2003 release and was imported by Hiram & Walker for the USA.

Legendary stuff, a total benchmark expression in…” Lees verder

Caol Ila 1983

91.66 / 100 Gemiddelde score

444 Stemmen & 129 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 1372.48
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 8 online shops

“Oh. My. God. On our whisky journey, there eventually comes a moment where we instantly realize: this is it. The one single malt we have always been looking for. Caol Ila 30 is the crown of the distillery's OB (bottle no. 0181, 55.1% ABV). Smoldering…” Lees verder

Lagavulin 18-year-old

90.11 / 100 Gemiddelde score

441 Stemmen & 103 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 931.43
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 23 online shops

“Unusually dry, almost refreshing Lagavulin with razor-sharp profile. For me clearly stands before the standard bottlings, but that was not to be expected otherwise. I'll need a sample from that ...” Lees verder

Lagavulin 25-year-old

92.27 / 100 Gemiddelde score

435 Stemmen & 89 Proefnotities

Gemiddelde prijs € 3994.52
Vergelijk prijzen
Beschikbaar in 18 online shops

“I must confess: I had my doubts. Could this 200th-anniversary edition of Lagavulin 25 fulfill the high expectations? With natural cask strength of 51.7% ABV (bottle no. 1573), the nose achieves perfect balance between delicate peatiness and…” Lees verder

Whiskybase logoWhiskybase

Whiskybase is gestart in 2007 met als doel om het grootste whisky platform te worden. Een community gedreven website gebouwd en onderhouden door whisky liefhebbers.



Whiskybase B.V.
Zwaanshals 530
3035 KS Rotterdam
The Netherlands

KVK: 60207205
VAT: NL853809112B01